Senior Pastor Tim and Polly have been married since 1983 and have served in pastoral ministry since 1984. Tim has earned degrees from Harding University, Assumption College and Vanderbilt Divinity School.

The Alexanders moved from Tennessee to be with PCC in 2013. Tim and Polly love to hike, having taken trails through the Smokys, Acadia, Yellowstone, Yosemite, Alaska and the highlands of Scotland. Future plans include a special anniversary trip to hike the Dingle Way in Ireland.
Pastor Alexander is committed to solid, expositional preaching emphasizing the centrality of Jesus in all things. 

Worship Director Aaron was raised in Topeka Kansas. He and his family moved to PCC in the fall of 2022. Aaron holds a Bachelors in Music Performance with a vocal emphasis from Washburn University in Topeka Kansas.

He and his wife Jordan have three children, Jedidiah, Benaiah, and Gideon. In his free time Aaron enjoys going on family adventures to parks, getting a good cup of tea or coffee, and playing board games.

Stefanie has been involved in Children’s Ministry at PCC since 2018 and has been the Children’s Ministry Director since 2022.  God has blessed her with a loving husband to dream and laugh with, three amazing children she has the privilege to homeschool, and a part-time position that combines her passion for children, young families, and Jesus.  At any given time, she can be found leading Bible Story charades, equipping volunteers, event planning, playing bass guitar on praise team, or searching for her ever-missing tea mug.

Eileen is the person you're going to interact with when you contact the church office.  She grew up on a dairy farm in Western New York, graduated from Cornell University, and moved to Fairport to marry her husband, Dan (whom she met at her mother's insistence).  They have been married since 1999 and have three children, Elizabeth, Emily, and Derek.  They have been attending PCC since 2013.  As a family they love to camp, to sing, and to string together terrible puns.